problem with third view and assonometry

[spinner84]

Good evening, everyone!
I am completely blocked on the annexed exercise where you have to get the view from above and an assonometric view.
Can someone please help me?
Thank you so much!

 

[MassiVonWeizen]

compass and ruler and find the view from above

 

[spinner84]

on the method there are!
on this exercise just no. in fact how much I have realized does not come back absolutely

 

[MassiVonWeizen]

I don't know what I've done

How do you know?
There's only one mistake.

You're not sure what you did? do it with solid edge and then analyze your design with that of 3d and think about the results.

 

[spinner84]

I would like to avoid solid edge for not having "helps", but to understand as far as possible independently where errors are.

 

[MassiVonWeizen]

I wouldn't see it as an aid, like an analysis method.
is a help if you use it to make the drawing, but if you use it to display three-dimensionally your two-dimensional design in the head then it becomes a tool.
after some exercises you will be able to view in your head without need of 3d physical

 

[spinner84]

How do you know?
There's only one mistake.

You're not sure what you did? do it with solid edge and then analyze your design with that of 3d and think about the results.

Do I still have to start from 3d on solid edge?

Concerning what I did I saw a possible error that I corrected as you see below

 

[MassiVonWeizen]

no, it is wrong.the material removal zone is never interrupted

 

[spinner84]

Then I just can't figure out where I'm wrong.

solid edge is still not perfectly in my strings.

 

[MassiVonWeizen]

you are wrong because you consider the 4 projected edge (from the left) as a continuous line, but it is crossed by the circular excavation.
draw them separately: before the circular excavation and after the rectangular excavation

 

[spinner84]

4th edge, so the error is on that line?

 

[MassiVonWeizen]

4 edges from left

 

[spinner84]

I misinterpreted your suggestion.
so the continuous line that is not correct is this

 

[MassiVonWeizen]

that of going to attempts is an unsuccessful method because it disperses the logic of reasoning.
the view is not yet correct.

 

[spinner84]

the problem is that I can't build the view in 3d to understand how this particular is done.

 

[MassiVonWeizen]

would be the case of learning to use solidedge
attached a pdf3d of the object. study

 

[spinner84]

I must learn this for good.

the pdf turns out white, or better with this error.

 

[MassiVonWeizen]

Devi aprlo con acrobat

 

[spinner84]

I tried to look at the pdf, but I think it doesn't represent the object I'm studying. comparing the side view in the 3d with that in the projection I have, this should be triangular, not trapezoidal. Am I wrong?

 

[MassiVonWeizen]

comparing side view in 3d with that in the projection that I have, this should be triangular, not trapezoidal

triangular? Really triangular? highlight on your drawing the 3 sides please... I'm curious as a monkey