• This forum is the machine-generated translation of www.cad3d.it/forum1 - the Italian design community. Several terms are not translated correctly.

model 3d asilo sant'elia terragni that software use? ?

  • Thread starter Thread starter VsVale
  • Start date Start date

VsVale

Guest
I have to support an integration for the drawing exam and the professor gave me to make a 3d scale model 1:100 of this architecture of lands, without telling me what software to use. I have always used sketchups, but the professor in question does not even consider it a design software and therefore I have to look for other "lides". I had mentioned using rhino or 4d cinema but I do not seem very suitable for designing an entire architecture, so I thought I was trying archicad.
What do you recommend?
 
I have to follow a 1:100 scale I had been advised rhino or cinema4d, but to me they do not convince much.
I was thinking about using archicad, but not knowing these software I don't know which one is better.
I have strong sketchup knowledge but in this case I can't use it.
What do you recommend?
 
Given the architecture of classic fascist mold I would opt for revit. on archweb you buy the dwg 2d to 18€, and with the autocad file under hand an expert user in a poor day has the beautiful 3d done
 
Tristan said:
Given the architecture of classic fascist mold I would opt for revit. on archweb you buy the dwg 2d to 18€, and with the autocad file under hand an expert user in a poor day has the beautiful 3d done
Click to expand...
I have already purchased the dwg, but unfortunately I am a student and I am not at all experienced. to ask someone to do so would be both expensive and useless from the educational point of view. but working with revit is easier?
 
compared to other software I mentioned in the question, i.e. rhinoceros,cinema 4d and archicad. considering that I have the "poor bases" of sketchup.
 
It's like saying if the bell tower's taller or the chocolate's gooder.
You're making confusion... apart from archicad other software you mention are designed to do completely different things.
rhino is a nurbs modeler and is very used for industrial design (with that much uses autocad), cinema4d is a modeling and rendering software with which you certainly do not pull out views and plan boards neither much less quotas and annotations
 
Tristan said:
It's like saying if the bell tower's taller or the chocolate's gooder.
You're making confusion... apart from archicad other software you mention are designed to do completely different things.
rhino is a nurbs modeler and is very used for industrial design (with that much uses autocad), cinema4d is a modeling and rendering software with which you certainly do not pull out views and plan boards neither much less quotas and annotations
Click to expand...
Here.. I thank you this my confusion arises from my computation ignorance in matter and from wrong advice and scattered data from the prof. but after a while I am studying rhino I realized that it was not really suitable for architectural design. I will throw myself on revit that I just downloaded, trying to pull something from the dwg I already have! thank you.
 
there are occasions when to draw certain forms can be effective the use of programs like rhino or 3ds max.
can happen for particularly sinuous and complex forms, this is not one of those cases.

with such a building, all straight walls, with revit or archicad go with "a gas wire", i.e. they are very efficient on these occasions.
 
gil said:
there are occasions when to draw certain forms can be effective the use of programs like rhino or 3ds max.
can happen for particularly sinuous and complex forms, this is not one of those cases.

with such a building, all straight walls, with revit or archicad go with "a gas wire", i.e. they are very efficient on these occasions.
Click to expand...
Got it. Thank you!
 
you in fact do not consider sketchup and recommends cinema 4d...
depends on the use you want to make of 3d, is it fundamental, how do you present it? What's up? drawings or just rendering? among the bim (cd for architecture) you have appointed archicad is the easiest to use.
Anyway, if I can give you advice, if you know how to use sketchup, use that, and tell him you used another one if possible, I don't really think I'm expert on your prof. :
 
vsvale, allow me a curiosity, architecture studies, engineering or design?
What subject does this prof teach?
 
gil said:
vsvale, allow me a curiosity, architecture studies, engineering or design?
What subject does this prof teach?
Click to expand...
engineering study of buildings, is an l23, but it is "daughter" of architecture. so there are both purely engineering teachings and architectural teachings. This professor teaches drawing an icar/17 and the 3d in question is absolutely not part of his teaching program, but it is his decision, to make me integrate 3 credits, since I moved from another faculty.
 
enri said:
you in fact do not consider sketchup and recommends cinema 4d...
depends on the use you want to make of 3d, is it fundamental, how do you present it? What's up? drawings or just rendering? among the bim (cd for architecture) you have appointed archicad is the easiest to use.
Anyway, if I can give you advice, if you know how to use sketchup, use that, and tell him you used another one if possible, I don't really think I'm expert on your prof. :
Click to expand...
the final presentation will be in print, and it must also include explosions. I had already thought of using sketchups and then maybe making it all, but I still haven't figured out whether it demands drawings or just renderings. Unfortunately, as I wrote to the other user, it is not a standard exam, but an integration that little centered on the teacher's program, so it is difficult for me to speak to us "normally" with this prof to find info from other students.
 
VsVale said:
compared to other software I mentioned in the question, i.e. rhinoceros,cinema 4d and archicad. considering that I have the "poor bases" of sketchup.
Click to expand...
I think with archicad you'll probably have less effort.
revit is very powerful and with those very effective forms, but it has a very steep learning curve.
Although he started using 3d modeling software in 1994, revit, at the beginning, made me feel sorry not little.
in fact the boys who come to me in the studio I make them go first with sketchup to hang themselves with the concepts of modeling 3d, then they pass to an old license of archicad (the 7.03) that I still activate, so familiar with the concept of parametric cad (almost bim) and crumble, and I just need a morning of assisted design to put them in a position to evolve themselves. only the smartest ones with the pc I bring them on revit.
 
study engineering of constructions, is an l23,
Click to expand...
then I can say without possibility of denial that the prof is a total incompetent is software cad does not understand a damn of nothing.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
44,997
Messages
339,767
Members
4
Latest member
ibt

Members online

No members online now.
Total: 20 (members: 0, guests: 20)
Back
Top